I liked the book version much better than the original online one. I didn't feel Patrick in the first version rang true at all. I skim-read the book when it arived, then next day started to read it again properly. I enjoyed it very much, I particularly liked Nick's singing lessons, nice to see Karen and Rowan on friendly terms again, and the shopping scene with the Dodds was great - loved Fob and Patrick enjoying each other's silence!

Hope Sally will do a sequel!